Model
Conversation levels
A disagreement about content is almost never about the content.
What do you use it for?
When a conversation gets stuck, recognising at which level the pain really lies — and steering the conversation there.
Content
The subject itself: what are we talking about? You recognise this level by questions starting with who, what, where and how. They draw out a story about the content.
- Summarising what has just been said
- Adding something to the subject under discussion
- Asking for an explanation or more information
- Checking whether the problem has been properly understood
- Offering solutions or making proposals
Procedure
The approach to the conversation: how are we going to do this? Think of structuring a meeting, giving it a different turn or bringing it to a close.
- Checking what the aim or desired outcome is
- Agreeing on timings
- Putting an agenda together
- Asking in which order the points will be dealt with
- Proposing a different approach: brainstorm first, then weigh up, then choose
Process
Atmosphere and emotions, which are often felt but not spoken. This is also called the 'below the waterline' level: people first give a weak signal, and only if you respond to it well do they come out with their real story.
The process level forms the base of the pyramid. If someone is irritated and you want to talk at the content level, little will come of that conversation. You will first have to take time for that irritation before you can move on to the content.
- I notice you're not comfortable with the situation — is that right?
- I hear you saying you're disappointed about how your manager treated you
- I can see you're not looking very happy…
- Making a remark about the atmosphere in the meeting
- Pointing out that communication is getting blocked somewhere
Finally
Content and procedure are more about working arrangements. Process — both the interaction and feelings, motivation and emotion — plays out at the relationship level. Usually someone first shows non-verbally that something is going on: slouching, frowning, sighing, talking loudly or very quietly, looking away.
Questions to ask
- At which level is the conversation now?
- Where is the real pain: in the content, the approach or the atmosphere?
- What happens if I name the process level?
Activities using this model
Consensus Assessment
The group gives one score together — and the conversation about it is the whole yield.
Conversation Café
A structured conversation about something complicated, in which nobody gets talked over.
Dilemma Discussion
A story with no right answer — and a group that discovers it disagrees with itself.
Fishbowl
A small group holds the conversation, the rest watch — and see things the speakers miss themselves.
Grief Walking
Space to share a loss, with someone who walks alongside and does nothing else.
Class Meeting
The class discusses for itself what’s going on and reaches a decision about it together.
Heard, Seen, Respected
Tell about a time you didn’t feel heard, and notice what it’s like to be heard.
Integrated~Autonomy
From “either together or on our own” to “how do we do both”, and the discussion tips over.
Campfire Conversation
A decision where every voice has been heard, including the critical and the worried ones.
Role Play with Subtitles
What people think but don't say gets spoken out loud by someone else.
Situation Set-Up
Someone literally places their work situation in the room, and immediately feels where it chafes.
Socratic Seminar
A conversation in which the group asks the questions and you say almost nothing.
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?