Activity
Dilemma Discussion
A story with no right answer — and a group that discovers it disagrees with itself.
- Time
- 25–50 min
- Group size
- 6–30
- Space
- Ordinary classroom
- Energy
- Calm
When do you use it?
For moral education, citizenship or after an incident: when you want people to learn to weigh things up rather than judge straight away.
Preparation
- Write a dilemma in which both choices cost something — not a choice between right and wrong
- Think up three probing questions that sharpen the dilemma
How to run it
- 1
Tell the story and stop at the choice. Give no hint of which way you would go.
- 2
Have everyone choose individually and write down their choice, with one argument.
- 3
Take stock of the split without discussion: who chooses A, who chooses B?
- 4
Have a few people from both sides give their argument. Probe: what does your choice cost?
- 5
Sharpen the dilemma with an extra detail — “and what if it was your brother?” — and have them choose again.
- 6
Close without judgement: what made this difficult?
What to say
The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.
“I'm going to tell a story and at the end a choice has to be made. There's no right answer — both choices cost something, and that's exactly why we're discussing it. First listen, then write down for yourself what you would do and why. Don't talk yet.”
Debrief
Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.
- What does your choice cost — who or what loses out because of it?
- What would have to be different for you to change your mind?
- Who shifted when I added the detail, and why?
- What made this dilemma difficult?
What can go wrong
Everyone chooses the same and the conversation stalls.
Your dilemma isn't a dilemma but a quiz. Sharpen it with a detail that makes the other side weigh more — that is what the extra step is for.
It becomes a debate in which people want to convince each other.
Move the question from “who is right” to “what does your choice cost”. Nobody can win that question and it produces the real conversation.
Someone feels judged for their choice.
Step in straight away and repeat that there is no right answer. Ask the critic what their own choice costs — that makes it mutual.
Variations
- Have small groups write a dilemma for another group.
- Combine with four corners: each corner a different consideration.
- Act the dilemma out as a short role play before you discuss it.
In the classroom
Suitable for ages 9–12
Core of citizenship education. Use dilemmas close to students' lives — cheating, keeping a secret, betraying someone — and not the classic philosophical puzzles.
Goes well with
The Best Summary
Four summaries side by side, and the group chooses the best — and learns what a good one looks like.
Conversation Café
A structured conversation about something complicated, in which nobody gets talked over.
Dialogue Card
A card that guides the conversation, so no facilitator is needed.
Experiences & Facilitation Tips
Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?