Activity
Integrated~Autonomy
From “either together or on our own” to “how do we do both”, and the discussion tips over.
- Time
- 60–90 min
- Group size
- 6–30
- Space
- Ordinary classroom
- Energy
- Moderate
When do you use it?
For the eternal battle between central and local, between uniformity and individual freedom.
Preparation
- Formulate the tension as an “either-or”, the way the group currently experiences it
How to run it
- 1
Name the tension as it currently plays out: do we have to do this uniformly, or do we let it go?
- 2
Collect in two columns: what does uniformity give us, and what does individual freedom give us?
- 3
Reframe the question from either-or to both-and: how can we be common and leave room at the same time?
- 4
Generate ideas that serve both sides. Use 1-2-4-All.
- 5
Choose the ideas the group wants to try, and agree how you’ll know whether they work.
What to say
The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.
"We’ve had this discussion before, and it’s always about whether we do it together or each on our own. Today we’re not asking that question. We’re asking: what do we gain if it’s uniform, and what do we gain if everyone does their own thing? Fill in both columns. And then we’ll look for ways to get both at once."
Debrief
Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.
- Which idea serves both sides?
- Where did we make something uniform unnecessarily that could have been left open?
- Where did we let go of something we should have shared?
What can go wrong
The group falls back on either-or.
Repeat the both-and question word for word. As long as the question is framed as a choice, people keep taking sides.
One column stays empty.
Ask the people who disagree with that side to fill it. That forces real consideration.
Variations
- Combine with Wicked Questions to formulate the tension sharply first.
In the classroom
Suitable for from secondary school upwards
Recognisable in any school team: do we all work the same way or can each teacher do their own thing? This format gets that discussion out of the trenches.
Goes well with
Critical Uncertainties
Draw four futures and work out what you would do in each — without predicting.
Six Thinking Hats
Six ways of thinking, explicitly divided — so that not everyone plays the critic at once.
Discovery & Action Dialogue
Seven questions that let the group discover that the solution is already somewhere in house.
Experiences & Facilitation Tips
Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?