Activity
Consensus Assessment
The group gives one score together — and the conversation about it is the whole yield.
- Time
- 45–120 min
- Group size
- 5–25
- Space
- Ordinary classroom
- Energy
- Calm
When do you use it?
For a self-evaluation or team reflection: how well are we actually doing this? Works on any topic you can capture in criteria.
Preparation
- Formulate the criteria and, for each criterion, a short description of what each level means
- Have everyone score individually beforehand
- Hang the criteria on flip charts around the room
How to run it
- 1
Have everyone give a score per criterion individually beforehand.
- 2
Transfer the individual scores to flip charts on the wall, using stickers. This creates a visible picture of the spread.
- 3
Stand at the chart for each criterion and look at the picture together. Where is the spread?
- 4
Ask the extremes to explain: who gave the highest, who the lowest, and why?
- 5
Reach one shared score. Not by averaging or counting, but by talking until the group can accept a score.
- 6
If consensus doesn't come, note the differing views and move on. The score is not the goal.
What to say
The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.
“On this chart are your individual scores. Together we're going to turn them into one. Note: that's not an average and not a vote. We talk until we have a score everyone can live with. And honestly, the number isn't what matters to me — it's the conversation we have to get there. Who gave the highest score, and why?”
Debrief
Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.
- Where was the greatest spread, and what does that say?
- What turned out to be a difference of opinion and what a difference in wording?
- Which criterion do we need to discuss again?
What can go wrong
The group starts calculating: the average is 2.4 so we say 2.
Explicitly forbid averaging. The average skips the conversation, and that conversation is the only reason for doing this.
It turns out that people interpret the terms differently.
Take time for that; it is often the most important outcome of the whole session. Pin down the meaning before you move on.
The manager decides the score.
Let them speak last, every round. And explicitly ask for the quieter voices before you fix the score.
Variations
- Assess not with numbers but with colours or with “now” and “in a year”.
- After the score, have the group immediately name what the next step would be.
In the classroom
Suitable for from ages 11, including secondary school
Very useful in a teaching team for self-evaluation. With students it works for jointly assessing group work against criteria agreed in advance.
Goes well with
Academic Controversy
First defend a position with full conviction, then switch sides — and arrive together at a shared position.
Farewell Round
Everyone gets something from everyone else, on paper — and takes it with them into whatever comes next.
Arena Conversation
Your clients talk about you while you listen and aren't allowed to say anything.
Experiences & Facilitation Tips
Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?