Skip to content
All activities

Activity

Academic Controversy

First defend a position with full conviction, then switch sides — and arrive together at a shared position.

Time
40–70 min
Group size
8–28
Space
Ordinary classroom
Energy
Moderate

When do you use it?

With a topic that has two reasonable sides, when you want a deeper conversation than an ordinary debate.

Preparation

  • Choose a topic with two reasonably defensible sides
  • Gather or create information that supports both sides

How to run it

  1. 1

    Divide the group into fours, and each four into two pairs: side A and side B.

  2. 2

    Phase 1 — prepare: each pair studies its position and prepares the strongest presentation.

  3. 3

    Phase 2 — present: each pair presents its position to the other pair.

  4. 4

    Phase 3 — discuss: the pairs challenge each other's arguments and defend their own position as convincingly as possible.

  5. 5

    Phase 4 — switch: the pairs swap sides and now present the opposing position as well as they can.

  6. 6

    Phase 5 — synthesise: the whole four drops the defending and works together towards a shared position that takes the best of both sides.

What to say

The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.

“You're in groups of four, split into two pairs. Each pair gets one side of the issue to defend — not because you have to agree with it, but to make it as strong as possible. First you prepare your position, then you present and defend it against the other pair. And then comes the twist: you swap sides and present the other pair's position, as convincingly as you can. Only after that, all four together, do you let go of defending and look for a position you can all stand behind.”

Debrief

Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.

  • What changed in your own opinion when you had to defend the other side?
  • What from both original sides ended up in the shared position?
  • What is the difference between this and an ordinary debate?

What can go wrong

After the switch, a pair keeps defending their original position anyway.

Remind them explicitly: in phase 4 the task is to present the other position as convincingly as possible, not to repeat your own opinion.

The synthesis in phase 5 becomes an empty compromise.

Press for detail: which element of side A and which element of side B is actually in it? A good synthesis is specific, not “a bit of both”.

Variations

  • Afterwards, have the group compare the shared positions of all the fours.

In the classroom

Suitable for from ages 11, including secondary school

Excellent for history, citizenship or social studies. The side switch is exactly what an ordinary debate lacks: it forces perspective-taking rather than wanting to be right.

Goes well with

Experiences & Facilitation Tips

Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.

Loading experiences...

Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?