Model
The consensus flowchart
Seven steps that guide a group through a decision without voting and without getting stuck.
What do you use it for?
A group that needs to reach a decision everyone supports, and structuring the conversation about it so that it doesn't get stuck in 'everyone has their own opinion' or jump too quickly to a proposal nobody really backs.
Why this model
Groups that make decisions without voting usually get stuck in the same place: someone makes a proposal too early, and the rest feel passed over. The flowchart enforces an order — first understand, then explore, only then propose — so that a proposal emerges after everyone has been heard, rather than being heard having to give way to the proposal.
It isn't a straitjacket you go through from step 1 to step 7 without looking back. See it as a map: if you notice a proposal meeting resistance, you go back to an earlier step instead of pushing on.
1. Introduce and clarify the issue
Share the background information and agree together exactly what the conversation is about: which question needs answering now? Skip this step, and half the group will end up talking past each other about different questions.
2. Open the discussion
Make room for everyone's needs and views before anyone looks for solutions. If ideas are already being put forward, hear them briefly and park them for the next step.
3. Explore ideas broadly
Gather as many different ways forward as possible. Explore the pros and cons of the options. Map out the most important concerns, needs and goals.
4. Form a proposal
Look for a solution that meets everyone's most important needs. That may mean combining elements from different ideas into one proposal.
5. Sharpen the proposal
Look for changes that make the proposal stronger. This is the moment for small corrections, not for a whole new proposal.
6. Test for agreement
State the proposal clearly and ask explicitly: is there a block, a reservation that still lets you go along with it, or an objection? Start by asking who is against — that makes it easier for people to voice a concern than if you only ask for agreement.
If there is a block, or too many reservations, go back to step 5 to sharpen the proposal, or back to step 4 for a new proposal.
7. Arrange implementation
Agree what needs to happen, by whom, and by when. Without this step even a decision everyone supports evaporates.
Questions to ask
- Have we reached step 4 while nobody has really been heard at steps 2 and 3?
- Is this a reservation someone can still go along with, or a real block?
- Do we need to go back to an earlier step, or just refine the proposal?
Seeds for Change Consensus Flowchartlink
Activities using this model
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?