Activity
Selecting Ideas
Three ways to choose without only the safe idea being left.
- Time
- 15–35 min
- Group size
- 4–30
- Space
- Ordinary classroom
- Energy
- Moderate
When do you use it?
After a brainstorm, when you have to choose which ideas go forward.
Preparation
- Decide beforehand which of the three methods you’ll use.
How to run it
- 1
Voting with stickers: everyone gets three votes and puts them on the ideas they want to pursue. The ideas with the most votes go through.
- 2
Four categories: choose one or two ideas per category: the sensible choice, the one that gives the most joy, the favourite, and the wild card.
- 3
Bingo: choose ideas that call for different prototypes, such as something physical, something digital and an experience.
- 4
Don’t choose just one idea and don’t choose only safe ones: take a range that preserves the breadth of the brainstorm.
What to say
The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.
"We’re going to choose, but not by simply voting, because then the safest idea is what’s left. We’ll choose in four categories: one sensible idea, one that makes us happy, one favourite that someone is attached to, and one wild card that we think could never work. All four go forward."
Debrief
Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.
- Which idea would have dropped out if we’d only voted?
- What attracted us to the wild card, and can we take that with us?
What can go wrong
Only the feasible ideas survive.
Use the four categories instead of voting. Voting almost always selects for safety.
A wild idea seems impossible to test.
Ask what attracted you to it, and test that aspect. The core you can build into another idea is often there.
Variations
- Combine: first vote to thin them out, then use the four categories to bring back the breadth.
In the classroom
Suitable for ages 8–12
Useful for choosing projects and in the student council. The four categories stop only the most popular student’s idea from being left.
Goes well with
Ecocycle Planning
Put all your activities on the life cycle — and see what you need to let go of to make room.
In the Cloud
Sort ideas into three clouds, from low to high pressure: prioritising without voting.
Mini-competition
Groups pitch their idea and rate each other, with a winner and without arguments.
Experiences & Facilitation Tips
Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?