Activity
Mini-competition
Groups pitch their idea and rate each other, with a winner and without arguments.
- Time
- 30–60 min
- Group size
- 9–30
- Space
- Ordinary classroom
- Energy
- Moderate
When do you use it?
When several groups have worked on a task and you want sharp feedback.
Preparation
- Number the groups and make sure the numbers are visible
- Decide the assessment criteria in advance and write them on a flip chart
How to run it
- 1
Form groups and have them all work on a group task for an agreed time.
- 2
During the feedback round, have each group pitch its product or idea to everyone.
- 3
The groups rate each other: they write each group's number and the mark they give on a slip of paper and put it in a sealed envelope.
- 4
As facilitator, collect all the marks, add them up and announce the winner.
What to say
The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.
"Each group will pitch in two minutes. While you listen, you give the other groups a mark on these criteria" — point to the flip chart — "but not your own group. Write the group number and the mark on your slip, and it goes in the envelope. Nobody sees what you give. At the end I'll add them up."
Debrief
Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.
- What made the winning pitch strong?
- What would you change about your own pitch now that you've seen the others?
- Was it hard to give a low mark, and what does that tell us?
What can go wrong
Everyone gives everyone else an eight and there's no difference.
Give explicit criteria in advance and ask for differences: 'give one group a high mark and one group a low mark'. Without that it becomes a round of politeness.
It turns into a popularity contest.
Besides a mark, ask for one concrete tip for improvement. That forces people to look at the content and also produces useful feedback.
Variations
- Besides a mark, have groups give one concrete tip for improvement.
In the classroom
Suitable for ages 9–12
Works well for group work and presentations. Have students rate against criteria agreed in advance, otherwise it becomes a popularity prize.
Goes well with
Ecocycle Planning
Put all your activities on the life cycle — and see what you need to let go of to make room.
Selecting Ideas
Three ways to choose without only the safe idea being left.
In the Cloud
Sort ideas into three clouds, from low to high pressure: prioritising without voting.
Experiences & Facilitation Tips
Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?