Activity
Mock Trial
A topic on trial, with prosecution, defence and a jury that really has to decide.
- Time
- 45–90 min
- Group size
- 10–32
- Space
- Ordinary classroom
- Energy
- Moderate
When do you use it?
For a topic with clear arguments for and against, when you want the group to really dig into a point of view.
Preparation
- Phrase the charge as a single statement
- Make role cards: prosecutors, defenders, witnesses, jury, judge
- Gather source material for both sides
How to run it
- 1
Phrase the charge as a statement: 'the smartphone is guilty of worse sleep'.
- 2
Assign the roles: a small group of prosecutors, a small group of defenders, a few witnesses, a jury and a judge. Assign them; don't let people choose.
- 3
Give both sides preparation time with source material. They think up arguments and the counter-arguments they can expect.
- 4
Hold the hearing: charge, defence, witnesses, rebuttal. The judge keeps time and manages turns.
- 5
The jury withdraws, decides and explains the verdict, not with 'we think', but with the arguments that were decisive.
- 6
Step out of role before you debrief. Say so explicitly: 'you're now just yourself again'.
What to say
The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.
"Today something is on trial. The charge is: ... You are the prosecution, you are the defence, you are the jury. Important: your role is not your opinion. You prepare the strongest case you can, even if you think differently yourself, especially then, because that's when you learn the most. Jury: you decide based on what is said, not on what you already thought beforehand."
Debrief
Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.
- First, out of role: what do you think yourself, now you've heard all this?
- Was it hard to defend a side you don't agree with?
- Jury: which argument was decisive?
- Which argument wasn't mentioned but should have been?
What can go wrong
Participants drop out of their role and start giving their own opinion.
Remind them of their role through the judge: 'the defence has the floor'. If that doesn't work, call a break and reassign.
It gets personal.
Step in straight away through the judge's role and refer back to the statement. This is why you assign roles beforehand instead of letting people choose.
The jury judges based on what they already thought beforehand.
Require the verdict to be backed up with at least two arguments that were raised during the hearing.
Variations
- Swap the roles halfway, so everyone defends both sides.
- Without a jury: the whole group votes at the end, before and after the hearing.
In the classroom
Suitable for ages 11–12, and secondary school
Strong for citizenship and history. Never choose a topic that touches on a pupil in the class; no trial about bullying in a class where bullying is going on.
A trial about a live conflict effectively puts a pupil in the dock.
Goes well with
Celebrity Interview
An interview instead of a presentation — and the room finally hears what it wanted to know.
Debate on Statements
Defend a position that isn't yours — and notice yourself adjusting your own opinion.
Future Search
Three days with all the stakeholders, moving from the past to common ground to concrete plans.
Experiences & Facilitation Tips
Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?