Activity
Debate on Statements
Defend a position that isn't yours — and notice yourself adjusting your own opinion.
- Time
- 45–90 min
- Group size
- 8–40
- Space
- Ordinary classroom
- Energy
- Moderate
When do you use it?
When a topic needs to be sharply articulated, or when you want people to put themselves in a position they don't share.
Preparation
- Formulate provocative statements you can genuinely disagree about
- Assign positions by drawing lots, not by preference
How to run it
- 1
Formulate a sharp statement and divide the group into for and against — by drawing lots, not on the basis of what people think.
- 2
Give both sides preparation time to think up their strongest arguments, and the counter-arguments they can expect.
- 3
Hold the debate with fixed speaking times: opening argument, rebuttal, closing.
- 4
Afterwards, have the rest of the group name which argument was strongest — not which side was right.
- 5
Step out of the roles and only then ask for people's own opinions.
What to say
The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.
“I'm drawing lots for who argues for and who argues against, so you probably won't get the side you believe yourself. That's the point: you learn the most from defending a position that isn't yours. Prepare your strongest arguments and also work out what the other side is going to say. And at the end we'll step out of role and only then will I ask what you think yourself.”
Debrief
Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.
- Which argument was strongest, regardless of which side it came from?
- Has anyone adjusted their opinion?
- What was it like to defend something you disagree with?
What can go wrong
It gets personal.
Step in straight away and point back to the statement. The drawing of lots helps here: everyone knows the position isn't the speaker's own.
People don't step out of their role.
Say it explicitly: “we're now stepping out of our roles”. Only then ask for people's own opinions, never before.
The statement is too tame.
Sharpen it until there is something to defend. With a statement everyone agrees on, there is nothing to debate.
Variations
- Let the sides swap halfway, so everyone defends both positions.
In the classroom
Suitable for from ages 10, including secondary school
Core of citizenship education. Draw the positions by lot and really pay attention to stepping out of role — otherwise the prosecutor stays the prosecutor.
Goes well with
Celebrity Interview
An interview instead of a presentation — and the room finally hears what it wanted to know.
Mock Trial
A topic on trial, with prosecution, defence and a jury that really has to decide.
Story Spine
Eight sentence starters that turn your explanation into a story people remember.
Experiences & Facilitation Tips
Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?