Model
The creation lemniscate
Four sides of an assignment that all need attention, or it turns into pushing and pulling.
What do you use it for?
Checking whether a programme or project is in balance: is there enough attention for the environment, the people, the team and the methods?
The principle of both-and
The creation lemniscate shows that effective programme management requires careful attention to each of four domains: the they side, the I side, the we side and the it side. A real creation process then follows naturally. If the aspects are out of balance, it becomes a matter of pulling and pushing and saying 'the boss wants it'.
The art is to take the 'have to' out of programmes: to breathe life into them by encouraging people to choose the things they really want, so that they take responsibility for the assignment they have accepted.
The they side gives nourishing and connecting power
The creation process always starts with the environment in which the programme takes place. This side answers the why, and provides the legitimacy. It is the side of the users and their wishes, of the client and their request.
The they side ensures embedding and prevents energy going into results nobody is waiting for. But this is not only where the nourishing energy lies: so does the resistance. Attention to the they side also means connecting with the people who have no interest in the programme, or sometimes even conflicting interests.
- What directly prompted the assignment?
- Which problem needs solving?
- In what kind of environment does the programme take place?
- Who wants what from the outcomes, and who are the sponsors?
The I side gives personal power
Motivation and support are determined by the extent to which those involved feel connected to the programme. The more room there is for their own input, the greater the commitment. Conversely, lack of commitment turns out to be one of the main reasons why a programme ultimately fails to deliver what was expected of it.
- Can I commit to the programme's aims?
- From which personal drive do I want to contribute?
- How can I best use my qualities?
- How do my qualities relate to those of the other team members?
The we side gives collaborative power
Collaboration is another factor in success or failure. It concerns the composition of the team, how much is invested in working together, the culture in the team and organisation, the availability of the necessary competences, and communication.
- What is our team's relationship with the client like?
- Do we dare to challenge the client on their role, and can we be challenged on ours?
- Have responsibilities and authority been properly assigned?
- How open is the climate in our team — do we challenge each other?
The it side gives shaping power
The it side is about the 'hard' methods and techniques: planning, budgets and estimates, control and steering. Points of attention are risk analyses, progress reports, the programme file and the contract. The it side makes things concrete.
- Is the programme clearly defined?
- Has the plan been concretely described and scheduled, with go/no-go moments?
- Is there a good quality plan?
- Are there good agreements about control and steering?
Questions to ask
- Which of the four sides gets too little attention with us?
- Where is the resistance — and do we have it in view?
- Is there balance between the sides, or are we pulling on one side?
Coppenhage, R. (2002). Creatieregie. Scriptumlook it up
Activities using this model
Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?