Skip to content
All activities

Activity

Helping Heuristics

Four ways of helping practised side by side, and you notice which one you always use.

Time
45–70 min
Group size
6–30
Space
Ordinary classroom
Energy
Moderate

When do you use it?

When developing coaching skills, or in a team where everyone mostly advises each other and rarely asks questions.

Preparation

  • Print role cards with a short description for each role

How to run it

  1. 1

    Work in threes: client, helper and observer.

  2. 2

    Round 1: the helper only gives advice and solutions. Five minutes.

  3. 3

    Round 2: the helper only asks questions and gives no advice at all.

  4. 4

    Round 3: the helper only listens and says almost nothing.

  5. 5

    Round 4: the helper may do anything, but deliberately and with a choice made beforehand.

  6. 6

    After each round: what did this do to the client? The observer says what they saw.

  7. 7

    Rotate so everyone has each role once.

What to say

The instructions as you would say them. Put them in your own words, but keep the order: get people moving first, then the details.

"We’re going to practise four ways of helping, and in each round you may use only one. First round: you only give advice. That’s the way most people choose automatically, so that will be easy. Second round: only ask questions, no advice at all. That’s a lot harder than it sounds. Observers: you watch what happens to the client."

Debrief

Without a debrief, an activity is just a game. Pick two or three questions; you don't need them all.

  • Which role was easiest for you, and what does that tell you?
  • Clients: which way helped you the most?
  • Observers: what did you see happening when the roles changed?
  • Which way do you use almost all the time in your work?

What can go wrong

In the questioning round, advice sneaks in disguised as questions.

Have the observer watch for it and name it. “Have you considered…” is advice with a question mark.

The listening round feels too uncomfortable.

That’s exactly why you do it. Shorten it to three minutes, but don’t skip it: the discomfort is the lesson.

Variations

  • Do only rounds 1 and 2 as a contrast exercise. That’s already instructive.

In the classroom

Suitable for from secondary school upwards

Strong in a staff team and on mentor training. For students, usable in a simplified form when learning to give feedback.

Goes well with

Experiences & Facilitation Tips

Experiences and recommendations from trainers, teachers and facilitators who have used this activity.

Loading experiences...

Is something wrong, or would you like to tell us something about this page?